Math students fear AI will take their jobs—they’re using it anyway | Scientific American

This post was originally published on this site.

Everyone has heard what the giants of mathematics think about artificial intelligence—the open letters, the op-eds, the predictions from laureates who have already cemented their reputation. Almost no one has asked the people whose future is less secure—the graduate students and postdoctoral researchers left to pick up the pieces after AI continues to plough through the field of math.

To take the field’s pulse, three math Ph.D. students—Anna Brandenberger, Hanna Mularczyk and Dora Woodruff—launched an online Google Forms survey in the wake of AI cracking problems that mathematicians had chased for decades. The survey quickly spread through word of mouth and department mailing lists: “We needed something that features the voices of grad students and postdocs as well,” Woodruff says.

Described in a preprint paper, the 268 responses from nearly 60 institutions paint a stark picture of a community in limbo: largely frustrated and anxious that AI is taking this field for a ride yet divided on what to do about it.


On supporting science journalism

If you’re enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.


Seven in 10 respondents say they’re now less likely to remain in math, with broad consensus that AI will make tenure-track jobs harder to get. Two-thirds report feeling less motivated to work on their research, with the growing possibility of a large language model (LLM) beating them to their goals.

“People have said things to me like, ‘I feel useless,’” Woodruff says. “It’s not just people’s jobs—math is a lot of people’s identities.” Some, she says, feel that “not only does their work not matter, but their minds and their creativity don’t matter.”

While senior mathematicians debate what the field might look like in 20 years, her and her colleagues’ respondents are worried about the immediate future. Woodruff sums up what many of her early-career colleagues are thinking: “In one year or two years,” as she puts it, “I don’t know if I’m going to have a job or funding,” she says.

But in spite of this universal malaise, young mathematicians are split roughly down the middle on the technology itself: about half are optimistic about AI’s potential for mathematics, while a third oppose its use—either outright or for creative mathematical work. The optimists come with an asterisk, though: among them, four out of five say they’re excited about AI in theory but strongly opposed to how things are unfolding in practice. Just 13 percent of all respondents are happy with the current trajectory.

Even among the respondents who do use AI—which is nearly all of them—not many seem to actually enjoy it. In written responses, many describe feeling pressured to use AI to keep pace, resulting in a generation of mathematicians who have been reluctantly mastering the very technology they fear could make them obsolete.

Seven stacked bar charts representing the results to seven different survey questions show how early-career mathematicians answered on a scale from zero to 10. Answers are colored dark red through pale red for zero to four, gray for five and pale green through dark green for six to 10. Red dominates nearly every bar. Among respondents, 77 percent would be unhappy if AI solved a problem they had worked on, and 10 percent would be happy. Additionally, 76 percent say AI will make tenure-track jobs harder to get, and 70 percent say their odds of staying in academic mathematics have decreased. The final question is the only one where green leads: 58 percent say they often weigh broader AI ethics when using it for research.

Woodruff cautions that the voluntary survey isn’t representative of all young mathematicians, and nearly all of its responses arrived before OpenAI published AI-assisted solutions to hundreds of open problems in October. But it shows that this headline-making year for math has come at a huge cost.

“A lot of people outside of math are looking at what’s happening in math now,” Woodruff says. “So far, we’re not doing a particularly inspiring job.”

Subscribe to Support Independent Journalism

Great science journalism requires human expertise, time, effort and creativity. And it costs money. That’s why I and the journalists here at Scientific American hope you’ll join our community.

When you subscribe, you are supporting staff and freelance journalists who are passionate about telling science stories that are true, important and compelling. Our editors and reporters are often experts in their fields, which means they understand the nuances of big discoveries and can untangle the breakthroughs from the hype. With a subscription, you are also supporting rigorous fact-checking to ensure the words we publish are precise and accurate. And you’re supporting original illustrations, graphics and photos that bring you closer to an advanced laboratory, an ice sheet in Antarctica or a space mission in orbit. You’re helping us craft other types of high-quality journalism as well: Our newsletters are carefully written, edited and curated by staffers you have or will come to know and love. Our Science Quickly podcast is based on original reporting, collaboration with editors and scientists and exacting production.

Subscriptions keep this engine running so we can continue to deliver thoughtful, rigorous and independent science journalism to you. In an era of viral misinformation, this work is crucial. If you value what we do, I hope you’ll consider joining us as a subscriber

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *