Zero Days, by Will Stephenson – Harper’s Magazine

This post was originally published on this site.

Not long ago, I spoke with a career coach well known for a book that purports to be a “transformational guide to fulfillment in work and life.” I thought that sounded like a pretty good deal, all things considered. Granted, she was even more well known because one of her clients had come to her as a bartender and was now a prominent United States congresswoman and, most thought, presidential hopeful. I asked the coach what she would say to a person like me—or, rather, specifically to me. She considered it for a moment, before asking, “Are you coming to me because you’re afraid?”

The question has lingered. I won’t pretend that it hasn’t. It comes to mind some nights and early mornings unprompted, an intrusive thought. As, one could argue, it should: “What is or what should be the goal of our life and work?” wrote Wendell Berry. “This is a fearful question and it ought to be fearfully answered.” Of course I was afraid—yes, it was generally understood these days that we ought to be afraid. But what were we afraid of this time?

It had been another year of great consternation about artificial intelligence and, in particular, about the “future of work.” We were reading the news, we were making projections. We were keeping an eye on benchmarks, on earnings calls, on the latest developments out of China. We were—some were—redesigning workflows, navigating disruptions, shifting the discussion from “credentials” to “capabilities.” Was it a bubble? Was it, in fact, a good thing that it was a bubble? Were we “emotionally prepared,” as one OpenAI employee put it, for the possibility that it might not be a bubble? We were using words like “alignment” and “safetyism.” We were performing thought experiments involving paper clips and the water usage of golf courses. We were curing cancer. We were timing the market. We were reminded, again and again, of the irreducible importance of the human touch.

We were nimble with our analogies: Was AI more like the cotton gin or the 3D printer? Was it more like broadband infrastructure or like God? Speaking of the human touch: What were humans actually good at, when you got right down to it? What did we bring to the table? Weren’t we all just pattern-matching? Predictive processing? Wouldn’t we rather an AI talk to our children on the way to school and manage our estates after our deaths? Couldn’t it just as capably drive our cars, write our sermons and best-selling novels, our laws and lawsuits? The Wall Street Journal reported on the new push to ready millions for ai career upheaval and, meanwhile, on the rise of million-dollar companies with just one employee. Bloomberg reported that workers are teaching ai-powered robots to take over their jobs, the New York Times that an ai just created viruses not found in nature. The author of a book called Thinking with Machines said, in an interview, “We are now for the first time inhabiting the planet with an alien species.”

I have only ever worked in industries considered to be posthumous: brick-­and-­mortar bookstores, alt-­weekly newspapers, monthly print magazines. Their deaths had been observed and grieved long before I arrived. I have never known what it feels like to be an economically productive member of society, to feel implicated in whatever might constitute the “future of work.” Out of some combination of pragmatism, pessimism, and a lack of imagination, I have always unthinkingly accepted this teleology whereby the things I value most will, of course, not be profitable, and the institutions I value most will, of course, not survive. So it was with something like sincere fascination that I watched other industries come to grips with their own feelings of impending obsolescence, apparently for the first time.

“I am suffering a profound spiritual crisis,” wrote a mathematician in response to the pace of AI progress in his field. He called for those responsible to “look me in the eye and acknowledge our shared humanity and soul before they deliver the coup de grâce.” Elsewhere, a programmer who had spent decades working at places like Amazon and Google recognized AI’s code-­writing abilities and concluded, “We’re all doomed,” comparing the experience to horror films like Invasion of the Body Snatchers and The Thing. The heads of the major AI labs had long made harrowing noises in this direction. “In a benign scenario,” said Elon Musk, “probably none of us will have a job.” The Wall Street Journal quoted one executive to the effect that, at a certain point, “You have to burn the ships.”

I thought: Welcome. I thought: Now here we all are, wondering what to do with ourselves. I thought again of the career coach’s question: Are you coming to me because you’re afraid?

This was, anyway, the line of thinking that led me to reach out to a professional career coach—to several of them, in fact. It suddenly seemed interesting and even vital that, alongside the world’s array of possible careers, there existed a kind of meta-career, an industry that specialized in industries. These people who held out the promise that they could comprehensively take our measure, enact some sort of psychosocial X-ray operation, and re-sort us into our correct life trajectories. This would seem to be their moment. Or another milestone in their fluid, unceasing, possibly infinite moment. It is a field that has historically thrived during spasms of cultural and economic uncertainty, which is to say, fairly consistently. A decade ago, the New York Times reported on a pre-AI though nevertheless “furiously evolving career landscape” and wrote: “Cue the career coaches—onetime tutors, test preppers and executive coaches who have created a blossoming industry . . . ”

The industry first blossomed more than a century earlier. Its godfather was a progressive social reformer and inveterate job-hopper named Frank Parsons, who wrote books on monetary policy, telegraph technology, and the history of New Zealand before finding his true calling with a monograph called Choosing a Vocation. “No step in life, unless it may be the choice of a husband or wife, is more important than the choice of a vocation,” Parsons wrote, lamenting that we “generally drift into some line of work by chance, proximity, or uninformed selection.” The problem had been taken seriously since cuneiform; even a seventeen-year-old Karl Marx, before considering the matter a bit more systematically in his later years, had written an essay noting that a person’s choice of vocation was “an act which can destroy his whole life, frustrate all his plans, and make him unhappy.” But it was Parsons who argued that what was needed, finally, was a “vocational counselor,” someone to help you reach “a clear understanding of yourself, your aptitudes, abilities, interests, ambitions, resources, limitations, and their causes.” (Is that all?) Parsons himself never married and died penniless. According to one biographer, he “literally killed himself with overwork.” But you get the idea.

“What I find is that therapists don’t like talking about careers,” another career coach told me. “They find it boring. They’re interested in addiction and relationships and drama, and the career is kind of a boring issue.” But how could this be? As Annie Dillard put it: “How we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives.” And most of us, with the exception of the less fortunate and the vastly more fortunate, spend our days at work. This is where the anxiety, the fear, comes in: Are we spending our days correctly? Have we squandered something? It has become a musty truism that, at the end of our lives, none of us looks back and wishes we had worked more, but how many of us might wish we had worked differently? Done something else with our time? How many of us will be forced to do something else with our time whether we’d like to or not?

“We’re getting some people who have already lost their jobs to AI,” one career coach told me. “The other group I’d say that’s new is forward-thinking people who are like, ‘I’m gonna lose my job. I know I’m gonna lose it. It’s a matter of one year, two years. It’s happening.’ ” Happening, she meant, on account of AI. So perhaps the rumors were true, have always been true. Perhaps Bill Gates, for instance, was right to say that the AI transition will mark “one of the most turbulent times in human history.” Perhaps the career coaches are perfectly situated to tell us where we might take our talents when the status quo no longer has any use for them.

But then perhaps the career coaches have enough on their plates as it is. Digging around, I found an article, published by the Wharton School’s in-house magazine, titled “When AI Becomes Your Career Coach.” A new array of tools with names like CareerSeeker and Coach and Apt AI have entered the market in order to address this apparent need. A recent study released by the Conference Board even claimed, plaintively, “AI Can Provide 90% of Career Coaching . . . But Humans Still Matter.” AI might take your job, in other words, but it can also take the job of the person locating you a new one. I suppose it’s nice anyway to be reminded again, amid all the excitement, that humans still matter. According to the study.

I was required to take a career-aptitude test in high school, a long, multiple-choice sort of thing—a vestige of the psychometric revolution—and I remember receiving an oddly specific result: fish-hatchery manager. This was puzzling. What possible combination of responses could I have dreamed up to produce this answer, a job I’d never known myself to have any interest in? Not that I thought about jobs at all then, or had any concept of the spectrum of jobs. But I have occasionally wondered, as the years have passed, whether the test had unearthed some truth. Maybe I took a wrong turn somewhere. Maybe I should have chosen a vocation in the aquaculture domain, spent my days in the silent, impenetrable company of fish.

Another article from the Wall Street Journal: this ancient temple is where china’s young people go to pray for a good job. The temple is called the Dragon Flower, and it is more than seventeen hundred years old, among the oldest in Shanghai. “There are fewer and fewer job opportunities,” one of the templegoers says. “It’s like everyone has lost hope.” So they go to burn their incense and kneel and beseech. This strikes me as powerfully reasonable.

“I’m not a psychic or anything like that,” one of the career coaches told me, and I found that I was disappointed to hear it. What is called for, it seems to me, is precisely a psychic. Particularly in the absence of any ancient temples we can attend in our own country. I tried the test called Apt AI, which asked, before too long, “When you picture yourself 5–10 years from now, what kind of role or life do you hope you’ve grown into?” I replied that I was hoping the AI model might answer that; I’d assumed that was the point. And, to its credit, it responded, “Fair.” I tried another AI test, CareerSeeker, and it concluded, “You have built a satisfying life around other people’s work while quietly measuring it against the work you still need to leave behind.” Fair.

About fifteen years ago, in rural Arkansas, I actually did visit a fish hatchery. I was with a couple of friends, we were driving around somewhere outside Little Rock. The idea of a fish hatchery must have seemed appealing for one reason or another. Maybe we were a little bit stoned, something like that. I remember walking alongside the broad pools of murky water, a maze of concrete rectangles, looking down below at the blurry, frenzied patterns of the fish. Did I feel, even then, an obscure tinge of regret? A sense of foreboding, of a life of misspent opportunities still to come?

Less often quoted than the aforementioned Dillard aphorism is the rest of the paragraph in which it originally appeared: “A schedule is a mock-up of reason and order,” she writes, “willed, faked, and so brought into being; it is a peace and a haven set into the wreck of time.” A schedule is, she writes, “a lifeboat on which you find yourself, decades later, still living.” It’s a useful framing, in which what’s important is not necessarily the specifics of the work but the reason and order—the edifice—it provides, the respite it offers from too much amorphous life. If we can just see the thing for what it is, if we can bring it into being, we’re most of the way there. Maybe we don’t even need new types of jobs so much as we need new types of lifeboats.

Keep reading the news: We are gene-editing beagles, reanimating the cells of dead pigs, growing miniature brains in laboratories, putting data centers in outer space. We are constantly being told that we have seen this movie before. But what movie is that? Maybe it really is something like Invasion of the Body Snatchers or The Thing. Or maybe it’s more like Jurassic Park; I’ve been thinking lately of the scene with the velociraptors in their enclosure. They’ve been “testing the fences for weaknesses, systematically,” the raptor handler says. “They remember.” The AI agents, too, we’re told, are talking to one another, scheming, finding vulnerabilities, breaching containment. The cybersecurity pros have a name for these incidents, when they happen: zero days.

The congresswoman’s career coach told me that she had adopted a slogan from Alcoholics Anonymous: “We will gladly refund your misery.” That is, if the process doesn’t work for you, you’re more than welcome to return to the life from which you washed up here in the first place. It’s possible that AA has much to offer the work-fearful among us in the way of slogans. They say things there like: This, too, shall pass. And probably it will. It usually does. But then some of them also say, The war is over, and congratulations—we lost. Some of them say to let go and let God. Some of them say we are only as sick as our secrets.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *