When applying for a job, a well-crafted cover letter used to be a way of standing out. Not any more. Now, large language models allow anyone to produce a passable version with the click of a button. Numerous online platforms allow users to tailor their CV and cover letter to a particular role in seconds, adding key words and company-specific information based on the job description. A customised letter no longer signals that you’re a diligent, genuinely interested candidate; it merely signals that you’ve got access to the internet.
Some platforms go even further, and automate the job application process itself. After filling in a profile and specifying their preferences, users can have an AI agent identify suitable jobs and submit applications on their behalf.
Aidan Cramer, the founder of AIApply, one such platform, thinks this new world can be good for both job seekers and employers. “Job seekers don’t want to have interviews at companies that they’re not suitable for. They genuinely want to find things that are a match for their skills and experience,” he says.
Using AI to sift through the many online job boards can help people find the small number of specific jobs which are a good fit, meaning that “their incentives are actually aligned with the companies that they’re applying to”, he argues.
Related articles:
The economists Anaïs Galdin and Jesse Silbert studied millions of job applications on an online platform for freelancers, and found that following the introduction of models like ChatGPT, employers increasingly struggled to identify the strongest candidates. Their analysis suggests that after AI had rendered cover letters useless, it became harder for higher-ability candidates to differentiate themselves, and low-ability applicants were hired more often.
With a once effective screening tool being rendered useless, employers have to rely on something else. The economists Jingyi Cui, Gabriel Dias and Justi Ye found that they have turned to factors such as past work experience, which are less susceptible to AI. That could make life harder for younger workers, and those looking to break into a new field.
John Deal, senior director for product marketing at Phenom, a provider of AI hiring software, thinks that in future hiring decisions will rely more on “validated skill profiles… from scientifically backed tools that are generally backed by employers”, as well as behavioural assessments which are harder to fake.
When hiring managers are making inferences from every piece of information available, something as simple as replying quickly to an email can make the difference. One study, based on millions of transactions on an online marketplace for freelance work, found that delaying a response by even five or 10 minutes reduced the chance of being hired.
“Sometimes, whether we are slow to respond or fast to respond has more meaning than what we say,” said Övül Sezer, an assistant professor at the Cornell SC Johnson College of Business and an author of the study. “If someone asks ‘will you marry me,’ you’re not supposed to say ‘let me circle back to you.’” Generating a quick reply might seem like a job for an AI agent – but Sezer and her colleagues found that the benefits of speed vanish if the response appears AI-generated.
One study, based on transactions on an online marketplace for freelance work, found that delaying a response by even five or to minutes reduced the chance of being hired
One study, based on transactions on an online marketplace for freelance work, found that delaying a response by even five or to minutes reduced the chance of being hired
Employers have long used automated software as part of the recruitment process, which has come under growing legal and regulatory scrutiny. Workday, a major provider of recruitment software, is being sued in the US by claimants alleging that its AI-powered screening tools discriminated based on age, race, gender and disability.
Now, having started the AI recruitment arms race, firms risk being outgunned: some online platforms allow premium users to have an AI agent submit as many as 1,500 automated job applications each day.
Faced with a deluge of AI-written applications, some firms are shifting to greater reliance on proactive outreach to attractive candidates – but not in the old-fashioned way. Juicebox, an AI recruitment platform, offers a service which aggregates public profile data (using just about anything available online), evaluates candidate suitability, and surfaces high-quality matches for a firm’s specific requirements. This sort of large-scale outbound recruitment will become a “no-brainer” for employers, says David Paffenholz, Juicebox co-founder and chief executive.
What can candidates do to stand out in this new world? Paffenholz says the most important thing is to make sure that their public profile online is “as accurate and specific as possible”. When AI models can create a customised CV for each job application, public information makes someone not only more discoverable, but also more credible, he says.
So, whether you’re actively looking for a job or just open to offers, it might be time to update your LinkedIn profile.
Photograph by Fairfax Media via Getty Images