The AI threat may be too speculative for drastic action, but financial plans can still be tested.Moor Studio/iStockPhoto / Getty Images
Financial advisors can help clients prepare for worst-case scenarios that may throw their finances out of whack, and a new risk that some are bracing for today is job loss from artificial intelligence (AI) disruption.
Anxiety among clients who work in sectors vulnerable to AI automation or are concerned about their children’s future employment is drawing attention to the importance of maintaining emergency funds and assessing the impact of AI on their financial planning.
“Fear is a great motivator,” says Simon Tanner, principal advisor with Dynamic Planning Partners at Investia Financial Services Inc. in Langley, B.C.
An advisor’s role is to hear clients’ anxieties and develop strategies to help alleviate them, he says. “The AI threat is too speculative right now for drastic action, but it’s not too speculative to stress test.”
Mr. Tanner has seen clients laid off from relatively high-level jobs, including programmers and software engineers. Although people concerned about unemployment typically anticipate a few months of searching for a similar position, he says, “with the AI threat, it’s, ‘What if my job no longer exists?’”
Jason Pereira, senior partner at Toronto-based Woodgate Financial Inc., says AI employment risk isn’t something his clients are typically anxious about, although many talk about their children’s job prospects.
He says that under the “Jevons paradox,” new technology should create more jobs than it displaces.
Companies are typically slow to adopt new technology such as AI, Mr. Pereira says, and people aren’t really seeing new systems being developed to replace them.
“Until we actually start seeing data pointing to actual layoffs, it’s not a thing.”
People concerned about job disruption, regardless of the cause, should start by living within their means, he says. “Make sure you can weather the storm before the storm happens.”
Mr. Pereira says there’s “more of a generalized anxiety toward, ‘What does the future hold for my children?’ And I get it. This is our industrial revolution, but the industrial revolution took a long time to change everything.”
Rona Birenbaum, founder and financial planner at Caring for Clients in Toronto, says AI concerns come up with retired or soon-to-be-retired clients who have children getting slow uptake on the job market.
With youth already launching later and struggling with affordability, advisors should ask clients how their kids are positioned jobwise and what level of support they might need, she says.
That could range from help with a down payment on a house in three years, or paying their first and last month’s rent, to offering long-term income support.
But Ms. Birenbaum says advisors should also encourage clients to be aware of the potential impact of AI on their own jobs.
“Do the research,” she says –which, ironically, could start with ChatGPT or another AI agent. “Say, ‘This is my job. This is my age. These are my skills. With how AI is developing, where are my exposures professionally? And how can I position myself to be a winner in this field?’”
Risk and cash-flow management are significant components of financial plans, she says. “We need to ask the client, ‘How are you seeing this affecting you?’ For many of them, it’s simply affecting their mindset.”
Advisors should offer “feedback that gives people confidence they’re going to be okay,” Ms. Birenbaum says, including stress-testing scenarios in which they face big pay cuts in the future. “A reality check is really important.”
Mr. Tanner says some people got away from maintaining adequate emergency reserves because of strong stock markets and rising home values in recent years. Many consider it good enough to have a line of credit on their ever-appreciating homes: “My house is a cash machine, so why would I hold onto liquid cash that I can have invested in the stock market?”
He says it’s prudent to stress-test financial plans for at least a year of unemployment from AI vulnerability, “particularly in single-income situations, and I have some clients in dual-income vulnerable positions.”
Clients should get back to cash-flow management basics by bolstering reserves, having difficult discussions and testing plans, he says. This could include the possibility of finding a skilled-trades job that pays much less than their current wage.
One option for people looking to change careers is to use the government’s lifelong learning plan to withdraw funds tax-free from a registered retirement savings plan to finance full-time education or training.
Mr. Tanner has had a couple of recent discussions with clients about that program but advises people to draw from other sources if possible rather than give up the benefits of compounding retirement savings in their RRSPs.
He thinks AI “is going to change tasks, increase capacity and reduce hiring before it eliminates occupations.” But if people’s worries bring them to forge better financial habits, Mr. Tanner adds, “I think that’s a good thing.”